NOTICE: This entry is long. Read tired.
Earlier this month European Court of Human Rights ruled , following a process initiated by an Italian mother, who crucifixes be removed from the classroom . The media, as usual, have contributed little to the debate. We are taught to those who favor the withdrawal of the crucifix saying his presence in the classroom undermines the freedom of parents to educate their children according to their beliefs without providing any compelling argument to support it. On the other hand, shows the defenders of the cross in the school saying each is free to have religion you want for a long crucifix has hung on the wall, and that the Christian religion is part of the historical and cultural heritage of Italy. For his part, Democratic Party, called the left but always careful not to displease their constituents believe, says that the crucifix does not bother anyone, and there is no need to move from where you are. This text intends to provide some arguments to justify why crucifixes should be removed from the classroom.
is clear that the mere presence of a crucifix in a classroom does not directly oblige anyone to be Christian. The proof is that children are Muslims, atheists, etc.. they see the cross in their school every day and why not convert to Christianity. The problem is that the symbols, however much we deny it to endeavor to defend those very often retained, not only represent a meaning, but also generate it. Even if we accept that the crucifix in the classroom does not represent that the state is secular (which is hard to accept), we face the problem that the state reserves a privileged place a symbol that identifies only a part, is This more or less, of the society. The meaning that is generated is "being Italian means, in principle, being a Christian, but anyone is free to not be * ." Take a Christian as a starting point, as quality that is assumed to be Italian, somehow implies that the non-Christian is not as Italian . Even leaving aside the debate over whether foreigners should or should not have full rights and duties in the host society, and whether they should be considered as Italian like others, must keep in mind that today There are full-blooded citizens deciding to change his religion or are atheists. If the State seeks to serve the whole society and all citizens, including non-Christians to identify with him and partake of it, is counter to generate the image of the prototypical citizen Christian. More would expect the State uses symbols to represent and promote common values \u200b\u200bacross the whole of society: equality before the law, right to participate in political life, freedom of thought, etc.
In the same vein I would like to refute, or rather redirect the argument so often heard that the crucifix represents the historical heritage of Italian society. It is true that our moral values, art and folklore drink directly from Christianity, which nobody questioned. If the walls of our schools we want to remind children how actors have shaped today's society, why not then reserve a place other items fundamentals such as Greek philosophy, the French Enlightenment, the British empiricists or Roman law? Not to mention the dubious educational value of a cross on the wall. For schoolchildren to learn how important is religion in shaping our society, there is available a lot more efficient means than a crucifix. Moreover, do not think any Christian not be of the opinion that the crucifix represents only a legacy of the past and not the power that the Church still holds. Some argue that the cross symbolizes human values \u200b\u200bbut, as explained in the section devoted to the arguments of the parties in the ruling of the Court , it is in any case the view of Christians, while followers of other religions are on the cross just a religious symbol.
Defenders of crucifixes in classrooms also used the argument that Christians are a majority, or that the majority of citizens come from Christian families. This justification is based on the erroneous principle that those who are the majority should have more rights than minorities. That decisions are taken by majority is democracy, but most are attributed to exclusive privileges itself is an abuse of power. Have a place in the public sphere to display symbols that have no other is, in my opinion, a privilege.
Several people with whom I discussed the matter of crucifixes in classrooms have taken up the issue of the veil of Muslim women. I understand that dealing with different issues, because one thing is what an individual decides to make his appearance, and over what the state does in an educational system of that society as a whole part and we all pay. On the issue of Muslim women exercising a public activity, where in addition to free individuals are representatives of the state, admit not having drawn conclusions yet.
In conclusion I would draw attention to the need in our time to reflect on how the symbols and what effects they have on the social fabric. Crucifixes in schools, street names, statues in the squares, the use of language, etc. not only testify to what we have been, but also talk about what we aspire to be.
0 comments:
Post a Comment